[Next] [Previous] [Up] [Top] [Contents] [Index]
Chapter one
European Tobacco Control Initiative: from Helsinki to Las Palmas
de Gran Canaria.
-
- Lluis Serra-Majem, MD, MSc, Ph D1
-
- José Ramón Calvo, MD, PhD[1], [2]
-
- Francisco Santana, MD, MPH1
-
- Juan Carlos Orengo, MD, MPH1
-
- Anselmo López-Cabañas, MD2
-
- Pedro Serrano, MD, MPH, PhD[3]
A bridge across Europe
he first Smokefree Europe conference, held in Helsinki in October
1996 was one of the most important events organised in Europe
on the problem of tobacco and health. The forum was a pioneer
initiative to coordinate activities to fight against the tobacco
epidemic in Europe; it was also advanced at a crucial time: the
tobacco industry had just stepped up its strategies to recruit
a young generation of smokers, and its efforts to create confusion
among the population about the relationship between tobacco and
disease.
In the old continent, the tobacco industry is still able to perform
aggressive media campaigns that would never be permitted in, for
example, the United States or Australia. One of these was the
campaign comparing the relative risks of certain diseases related
to tobacco exposure to the risks of drinking chlorinated water
or consuming cookies or pepper.
The Helsinki meeting opened the door to sharing experiences between
those European professionals worried about the health consequences
of tobacco, people active in legislation, young people, women
and people active in the media. In addition, Finland and other
north European countries. have a history of effective measures
against the tobacco industry that need to be presented to southern
and eastern European countries, including Spain. It is partly
for this reason that the second Smokefree Europe conference will
take place in Gran Canaria, in February 1999.
Tobacco consumption in the Canary Islands
The choice of the Canary Islands for this event has special importance
for several circumstances:
- Some 37% of adult Canarian inhabitants smoke, including nearly
40% of health professionals.
- Tobacco is an important economic resource for the Islands, employing
over 2,800 people and accounting for an annual economic turn over
of Pta 72,000 million (1 ECU= 168 Pesetas). It is an unique European
location of four of the leading multinational tobacco industries.
- The publicity investment of the tobacco industry in Canary Islands
is high, with more than Pta 1,700 million invested last year by
one of the tobacco giants alone.
- The economic costs of the tobacco impact on the health system
is estimated to be over Pta 16,000 millions, more than 10% of
the budget of the Canarian Health Service.
- It is estimated that smoking is responsible for 14.7% of deaths
in the Canary Islands, representing 1,475 deaths every year, compared
to the 2,800 employed in the tobacco industry
These facts underscore the magnitude of the tobacco problem in
the Canary Islands and Spain, and the importance of organising
an international forum in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria as a follow
up to the Finnish event.
Venue
The second Smokefree Europe conference will be held in Las Palmas
de Gran Canaria. The Canary Archipelago is made up of seven islands
(Lanzarote, Fuerteventura, Gran Canaria, Tenerife, Gomera, La
Palma and Hierro) with a total surface of 7.242 km2 and a population
of 1.562.000 -- 80% of which is concentrated on the islands of
Gran Canaria and Tenerife.
New health policy against tobacco
The initiative against smoking started in the Canary Islands a
few years ago. Last year the regional government approved a health
plan that places anti-smoking activities as a priority. A conscious
system to analyse perceived problems by different population groups
was established, in addition to monitoring the extent and seriousness
of different health problems, risk factors, and responsiveness
to intervention. Community participation is probably one of the
most important features of the development of the health plan,
focusing on consultations with three broad population groups:
general population, health professionals (including: professional
organizations, universities, the school of medicine and health
sciences, scientific societies) and opinion leaders (including:
public associations, institutions, political parties, media, trade
unions, regional parliament members).
The first included a survey of 124 focal groups in 72 municipalities
that fielded questions on perceived health needs, health problem
prioritisation, the relationship between lifestyles and environment
and health status, and opinions on actions to be undertaken at
individual and governmental levels. Results from this survey showed
that tobacco and alcohol were considered the main perceived problem
and the first priority.
The consultation with health professionals included physicians,
nurses, pharmacists, dentists, psychologists, health workers and
vetenerians. The survey technique to estimate the opinion of some
1,199 health professionals using an Anchord Rating Scale rated
from 1 to 6 in exploring health status, living conditions and
provision and use of health care services. Alcohol and tobacco
were rated as the third priority, after diabetes and cardiovascular
diseases, by this group of health professionals.
And the delphi survey of opinion leaders and health experts used
the Hanlon method to set priorities--comprising seriousness of
the health problem, responsiveness to intervention, feasibility,
possibility to evaluation, efficiency and costs. Smoking was rated
as the third serious lifestyle problem after illegal drug use
and alcoholism, and as the fourth health problem after cardiovascular
diseases, cancer and diabetes.
Because of this, cutting smoking is a health priority for the
Canarian Health Service--which is the reason for the Service's
support, together with the University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria,
for the development of the second European conference.
One of the initiatives on the agenda of the Canarian government
is the development of a special tax on alcohol and tobacco -never
before imposed in Spain.
Many institutions and organizations are supporting the organizing
committee: the Spanish Ministry of Health, the National Committee
for Smoking Control, Spanish Cancer Society, autonomous local
governments, professional organizations, and non-governmental
organization. They are joining our efforts to activate people's
consciousness, putting tobacco on the political agenda, and permitting
much needed legislative support to attain the health objectives
included in the Canarian Health Plan. One of the initiatives on
the agenda of the Canarian government is the development of a
special tax on alcohol and tobacco -never before imposed in Spain-
to finance the health consequences of alcohol and tobacco use
and health promotion activities. The move is opposed by the Canarian
ministries of finance and industry. Prior to the Smokefree Europe
forum, the government of the Canary Islands and the University
of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria will hold a workshop of over 100
experts from all around the world to develop a strategic plan
for the Canary Islands to resist the tobacco epidemic in this
particular geographical area.
The final aim is clear: a Smokefree Europe, north and south. n
TABLE 1 MORTALITY ATTRIBUTABLE TO SMOKING IN THE CANARY ISLANDS
(1995)
| Cause of death | Code CEI-9a | Deaths 1995 | PAP (%) * | Attributable deaths
|
| | | Males | Females | RR | Males | Females | Males | Females | Total
|
| IHD | 410 a 414 | 785 | 622 | 1.8 | 28 | 17 | 220 | 106 | 326
|
| CVA | 430 a 438 | 391 | 484 | 1.8 | 28 | 17 | 109 | 82 | 191
|
| PVD | 443 | 15 | 15 | 1.5 | 19 | 11 | 3 | 2 | 5
|
| COPD | 490-496 | 266 | 105 | 12 | 84 | 74 | 223 | 78 | 301
|
| CLB | 162 | 425 | 61 | 10 | 81 | 70 | 344 | 43 | 387
|
| CLTMP | 140 a 149 | 92 | 11 | 6 | 70 | 56 | 64 | 6 | 70
|
| CL | 161 | 71 | 2 | 6 | 70 | 56 | 5 | 1 | 6
|
| CE | 150 | 57 | 8 | 5 | 66 | 51 | 86 | 4 | 90
|
| CP | 157 | 71 | 54 | 2 | 32 | 20 | 23 | 11 | 34
|
| CUB | 188 | 86 | 10 | 2.5 | 42 | 28 | 36 | 3 | 39
|
| CK | 189 | 22 | 7 | 2.5 | 42 | 28 | 9 | 2 | 11
|
| CC | 180 | - | 32 | 2.1 | 34 | 22 | - | 77 |
|
| DNB | 765, 769 y 770 | 10 | 6 | 1.8 | 28 | 17 | 3 | 1 | 4
|
| SDS | 798 | 16 | 5 | 1.5 | 19 | 11 | 3 | 1 | 4
|
| Total | | 2307 | 1422 | | | | 1128 | 347 | 1475
|
| Total deaths | | 5655 | 4423 | | | | | |
|
| P(RR-1)
*PAP= -------- x100 | | | | | | Source: ISTAC, 1995.
Serra-Majem et al, 1997. |
IHD is ischaemic heart diseases, CVA cerebrovascular diseases,
PDV peripheral vascular diseases, COPD chronic obstructive pulmonary
diseases, CLB lung cancer, CLTMP cancer of the lip, mouth and
pharynx, CL cancer of the larynx, CE cancer of the oesophagus,
CP cancer of the pancreas, CUB cancer of the urinary bladder,
CK other cancer of the urinary organs, CC cervical cancer, DNB
diseases related to smoking during pregnancy, SDS sudden infant
death syndrome.
Correspondence:
-
- Professor Lluis Serra-Majem, MD, Ph D
-
- Chairman,
-
- Department of Public Health
-
- School of Health Sciences
-
- University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria
-
- P.O. Box 550
-
- 35080 LAS PALMAS DE GRAN CANARIA
-
- Spain
-
- Tel. 3428-453476
-
- Fax. 3428-453475
-
- e-mail. serra@mpsp.ext.ulpgc.es
Rising Profile of Smoke-free Concerns
...attitudes toward smoking are changing among the coming generation
of health professionals, and are likely to be reflected in patient
counselling.
According to researchers at the University of Las Palmas School
of Medicine, a central problem of tobacco use is its prevalence
among health professionals. Some 40% of Spanish nurses and physicians
smoke, and do not include counselling on smoking hazards as part
of their therapeutic strategies.
But a survey conducted in 1996 by the researchers of the smoking
habits of students and teachers at the medical school and found
some encouraging signs of declining tobacco use. The sample survey
polled 154 students and 65 teachers. The number of regular smokers
among the teachers was 38.5%-67.7% were former smokers. Of the
students, 31.3% have smoked in the past and 18.3% still did.
The study is seen as evidence that attitudes toward smoking are
changing among the coming generation of health professionals,
and are likely to be reflected in patient counselling.
Recent target
Efforts to control tobacco use and conduct treatment programmes
for smokers are comparatively recent phenomena in Spain, dating
from the early 1980s. Studies show a steadily increasing interest
in smoking prevention and treatment as well as a rise in the range
of anti-smoking programmes.
In 1996 the proportion of smokers in the population was put at
36% of the nearly 40 million population. Morbidity studies attribute
40,000 deaths each year to tobacco use, and WHO figures put the
proportion of lung cancer deaths due to smoking at nearly 90%.
Studies at the Universidad Automa de Madrid show that for every
gram increase in tobacco consumption per capita per day since
1940 there has been a corresponding increase in lung cancer deaths
by 20%.
Sun, sea and smoke
By 1995, however, cigarette smoking was dropping by about 1%-1.5%
annually, reflecting the impact of no-smoking campaigns and public
health education. These have in part focused on limiting tobacco
advertising, in particular that directed at young people.
Spain's popularity as a holiday destination does not escape the
tobacco industry's marketing gambits. The advertising of fun and
lifestyle products rockets each summer, with about 30% of ad companies'
outdoor commercials devoted to summer campaigns. Prominent among
the big names are Marlboro and Winston.
...youth is the target, and the Canary Islands a prominent focal
point due to its leading position in the holiday industry.
A studies conducted at the University of Las Palmas and the University
of Santiago de Compostela stress that youth is the target, and
the Canary Islands a prominent focal point due to its leading
position in the holiday industry. In 1995, researchers point out,
just one tobacco company spent US$14,000 alone in advertising
on the Islands. The content of the commercials is clearly directed
at recruiting young smokers as the advertising is frequently linked
to special offers for products such as bikes, Walkmans, and free
concert tickets.
More attention to curtailing cigarette adverts was prompted in
1995 when Philip Morris began advertising for smokers' rights
and the next year when the company launched its campaign to undermine
efforts to cut passive smoking. Similarly, more attention is being
placed on limiting smoking in public places, a development which,
according to a 1995 opinion poll conducted by the Centro de Investigaciones
Sociologicas, has over 43% public support.
On the defensive
The tighter environment faced by the tobacco companies has resulted
in a price war to keep sales buoyant. Cheaper brands have come
on the market displacing more expensive ones, and in some cases
the cost of low price light cigarettes, such as Philip Morris'
L&M, has been cut. At the same time, although overall sales of
cigarettes recorded by tobacco companies often fluctuate, the
trend is downward. The tobacco monopoly Tabacalera recorded 4%
lower net profits for 1996 and a decrease in cigarette sales by
4.4%.
The drop in cigarette sales does not necessarily reflect rising
anti-smoking awareness. A more likely explanation is the erratic
influx of contraband cigarettes into the country. About 30% of
Marlboro and 60% of Winston brands are contraband. In 1996, Spanish
customs stopped a shipment of some 600,000 cartons of cigarettes
worth US$1.4 million that had travelled from Finland. Authorities
traced the consignment to a Russian source, and suspected that
it was part of a mafia operation. Though cigarette smuggling is
not a central campaigning concern of the anti-smoking lobby, it
is nevertheless seen as an additional factor responsible for the
prevalence of tobacco in society, and in particular its intensive
sale and consumption in holiday resorts. n
Mark Waller
Smoking Cessation Intervention in Gran Canaria.
Since November 1995 the University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria
has been holding smoking cessation courses targeted at the general
public.
The course programme applies a multiple component programme that
includes the progressive reduction of nicotine and tar. The courses
comprise five weekly sessions and the provision of a short self-help
manual. The positive results of the courses have encouraged the
organisers to ensure they continue.
The results of data collected through participation in the courses
show that more women than men have been drawn to the courses.
They also attract a high percentage of heavy smokers--89% smoke
20 or more cigarettes a day. The results show that the best results
have been obtained through small group sessions, weekly periodicity
and the use of the support-manual. n
[1] Department of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, University
of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria.
[2] Tobacco Unit, Faculty of Health Sciences University of Las
Palmas de Gran Canaria
[3] Canarian Health Plan and Research Unit, Canarian Health Service,
Ministry of Health and Consumers, Autonomous Government of Canary
Islands
The authors acknowledge Miss Sandra Marrero for her help in
preparing this paper.
Smoke Free Europe - A Forum for Networks - 14 AUG 1997[Next] [Previous] [Up] [Top] [Contents] [Index]